Prison announcement not all good news

The Justice Ministry has issued releases claiming major benefits.

To the Editor:

Lamenting democratic dysfunction, journalist Andrew Coyne (Vancouver Sun Oct.3) observed “Governments refuse to answer questions, release documents, give out correct figures or otherwise meet their . . . obligations”.

This sounds like the BC Justice Ministry respecting economic and social impacts of the proposed Oliver prison.  At Oliver’s October meeting, BC Corrections (BCC) Director Marnie Mayhew stated that law prevents release of impact assessments.  What contrivance: simply append studies to cabinet documents to render them confidential!

That follows BCC’s blotting out 339 of 343 pages of requested studies.  These are presumably incomplete, inadequate, or arrive at conclusions unfavorable to a South Okanagan prison location.

The Justice Ministry has issued releases claiming major benefits.  BCC’s Brent Merchant asked how could prison-related spending not benefit this area. The answers are basic.  First, there are leakages based on contracts and materials being sourced elsewhere for cost savings. Second, there are costs and risks.  Such costs can be direct and indirect.

Direct costs include increased requirements for local policing.  BCC stated those costs are not the BC Government’s responsibility. BCC claims to look after their clients’ health, yet statistics on the 300 cell North Fraser Pretrial Centre report 510 inmate visits to regional health services in 2012.

Indirect costs come in the form of a rural prison’s detrimental effects on real estate numbers and post-construction economic growth, as shown in a detailed, non-partisan U.S. study. BCC dismissed that study as “American”, later admitting that no similar Canadian research exists.

BCC claimed to be an “evidence based” organization, yet failed to produce any on impacts.  They appear to simply pursue getting jail capacity built. That’s easiest in communities with fragile economies, yet these are the ones where job opportunities, available housing and support services for released and probationed inmates are least available.

BCC indicated that 2,500 inmates are in B.C. provincial facilities. With 756 inmates coming to the Oliver prison, the RDOS (with population less than two per cent of B.C.’s) will be picking up policing and other costs to deal with the effects of hosting 30 per cent of BCC clients.  BCC advises that for every incarcerated inmate, eleven more are in community supervision, yet there are no plans to hire more probation officers. This suggests that cell and supervision capacity should be located where community support capacities are greater.  Moreover, prison locations are more efficient closer to actual centres of demand and in communities with greater capacities.

The Oliver prison location needs re-assessing given:

a) considerable evidence against location in a low-population rural area.

b) secrecy.

c) apparent reliance by Corrections BC on expedience rather than analysis.  Failure to do so puts future economic and social prospects of the South Okanagan at risk.


Denis O’Gorman, Penticton



Just Posted

Highway 97 rock slide north of Summerland beginning to stabilize

Costs of road work so far estimated at between $300,000 and $350,000

Family Day long weekend expected to be sunny and cool in South Okanagan

Flurries forecasted for the first half of the weekend, followed by bluebird skies and milder temps

Anonymous donor offers to match donations for Keremeos youth drop-in centre

A fundraising campaign is underway to start a youth drop-in centre in Keremeos

More snow on the way for Okanagan-Shuswap

Up to 5 cm of the white stuff could fall across the Okanagan - Shuswap on Friday

Family Day in the South Okanagan

Find out what your community has planned for Family Day on Feb. 18

VIDEO: Canada’s flag turns 54 today

The maple leaf design by George Stanley made its first appearance Feb. 15, 1965

Expect delays on Highway 1 west of Golden due to vehicle fire

Expect delays while driving Highway 1 between Golden and Revelstoke. Drive BC… Continue reading

Eight cases of measles confirmed in Vancouver outbreak

Coastal Health official say the cases stem from the French-language Ecole Jules Verne Secondary

Semi loses control on Highway 97A in Shuswap

Slippery roads contribute to crash of transport truck carrying tires

Plecas won’t run in next election if B.C. legislature oversight reforms pass

B.C. Speaker and Abbotsford South MLA says he feels ‘great sympathy’ for Jody Wilson-Raybould

Infighting at Kelowna Yacht Club makes it to court

Marc Whittemore, a local lawyer and prominent member of the club, filed a notice of civil claim Feb. 1

Workshop with ‘accent reduction’ training cancelled at UBC

The workshop was cancelled the same day as an email was sent out to international students

Former B.C. premier Gordon Campbell accused of sexual touching

Accuser went to police, interviewed by Britian’s Daily Telegraph

Most Read