Staggering federal payroll costs help explain Ottawa’s runaway deficits

Canadians have been asking the Harper government some tough questions in recent months


Canadians have been asking the Harper government some tough questions in recent months. Questions like: why has Canada’s federal debt jumped over 30 per cent since 2008, to over $600 billion? Why did the government miss its deficit target by $1.4 billion last year, and what is pushing this year’s deficit forecast higher by more than $5 billion to $26 billion?

We got an important answer recently, not from the government, but from the Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO), an independent research team established to give MPs the straight goods on the nation’s finances.

Figures released by the PBO show that, contrary to all the talk we’ve been hearing about cutbacks, Ottawa’s payroll is getting out of control. Recent attempts to rein in federal payroll spending amount to the Conservatives bailing out the Titanic with a soup spoon.

The numbers don’t lie: when Stephen Harper took office in 2006, there were 336,831 people working for the federal government. Fast forward to March of 2011 – just before the Prime Minister won his coveted majority – and Ottawa’s full-time payroll had ballooned to 379,760, an increase of 42,929 staffers.

The all-in cost for this high-priced talent – including wages, benefits, pension contributions, extended medical, dental, disability insurance, and sick leave – went from $29 billion to $42.3 billion – a staggering increase of 46 per cent in just five years.

Even more troubling, especially to working Canadians who thought they elected a fiscally conservative government to Ottawa, is the spectacular jump in payroll costs for the average federal employee: from $86,000 in 2006 to $111,379 five years later.

There is hope on the horizon: the government cut the federal payroll by 4,200 positions last year, and Treasury Board president Tony Clement recently reported the elimination of another 10,980, on the way to cutting 19,200 by 2014.

But here’s the problem: even if the government succeeds in making the cuts they’ve committed to, they will still have 12,000 more people on the federal payroll than the day they took office. According to PBO projections, all the built-in inertia in Ottawa’s staffing system – union contracts, job reclassifications, pension increases and the like, will push the average cost of each of these people to $129,800. So Ottawa’s payroll costs will rise to $45.3 billion – $3 billion more than they were last year.

The government’s defenders will say that it simply isn’t possible for any government, even a conservative government, to grapple with the massive Ottawa bureaucracy and keep a lid on payroll costs. But the Parliamentary Budget Office says otherwise. When Jean Chretien took office in 1993, there were 345,942 full-time federal employees. Five years later, there were 288,484, a reduction of 57,458. And instead of boosting payroll expenses by $13 billion, as the Conservatives have done, Chretien actually cut payroll expenses by $2.3 billion, a savings of 13 per cent.

Sadly, Chretien and his successors failed to sustain the progress he made in his first five years in office. In fact, when the federal payroll dropped last year, it was the first reduction since 1998. Ottawa’s payroll costs have grown at an astounding compounded annual rate of 7.1 per cent since the Harper government took office, compared with 3.1 per cent for Canada’s business sector.

In recent years, the federal Conservative party has taken steps to legally protect its brand identity, even going to court to prevent other candidates in elections from using the word ‘conservative’ on their campaign signs.

Unless the Harper government takes serious steps to get its payroll costs under control, taxpayers should really consider a prosecution for false advertising.


By Gregory Thomas


Canadian Taxpayers Federation



Just Posted

Okanagan-Shuswap weather: weekend rain

Environment Canada forecasts continuing bad weather for the start of the weekend

New homes in Penticton for women and children leaving violence

The B.C. municipal affairs minister scheduled to be in Penticton Friday for new homes announcement

Spirits of missing and murdered felt along the Highway of Tears

A Penticton man is feeling the spirits of the missing and murdered women along the Highway of Tears

Eastside Road re-opened following repairs

Section of Eastside Road closed by the Ministry of Transportation is open after repairs.

Update: Administrative error results in do-over for South Okanagan dangerous offender’s trial

Ronald Arthur Teneycke will return to Penticton court on June 5 to start the process over

600 new campsites coming to provincial parks and recreation sites across B.C.

Tourism Minister announced half of the new spots to 13 most popular provincial parks

Spring rain needed as B.C. sees one of the lowest snowpack levels in 40 years

Snowpack levels in B.C. recorded on May 15 were similar to those in 2015 and 2016

Lake Country Council passes motion to have more regulations on vaping

With vaping on the rise and its health risks uncertain, Gambell wants provisions in place

Cars parked at Voyager RV get stuck underneath fallen rock

One car owner, was on his way to a funeral

RV trailer fire suppressed in West Kelowna late Thursday night

West Kelowna Fire Rescue aided BC Wildfire Services near Bear Creek Park

Court to rule on B.C.’s pipeline permit law in crucial case for Trans Mountain

A panel of B.C. Court of Appeal judges has been mulling B.C.’s constitutional reference cas

Theresa May to quit as party leader June 7, sparking race for new PM

The new Conservative leader will become prime minister without the need for a general election

Kelowna golf course supports MS research

Shadow Ridge Golf Club hosts golf by donation May 27

B.C. man who fell off cliff returns there to rescue eagle from vulture attack

Nanaimo’s James Farkas, who broke his hip in a fall, saves eagle on same beach months later

Most Read