Legislators, regulators and validators

I had a fascinating exchange with the CEO of the Pacific Carbon Trust (PCT) the other day. I’m investigating the structure of the Trust and some of the projects it has approved for “carbon offsets.” The whole concept of carbon offsets is questionable to begin with, some experts call it the worst kind of “voodoo economics” possible. When cash the strapped public sector is forced by government to give up $25 million every year (money that should be going to schools, hospitals, seniors’ facilities and other public programs) in order to buy these “offsets” I think it’s entirely appropriate to question where that money is going.

As most people should know by now the public money in the PCT is only available to the private sector. Luxury resorts and hotels, greenhouses, Lafarge and Encana have been the recipients of this public money so far. The CEO of the PCT has informed me that there will be another 25 projects announced before the end of June.

In investigating the Encana project that the Trust helped to fund, I came across what I believe are valid questions about whether Encana should have qualified for the trust’s money. Morally and ethically, I struggle with giving public money to a highly profitable company that is also the largest emitter of greenhouse gases in B.C. In fact, while the Trust is giving our tax money to Encana for “reducing” its carbon emissions by 84,000 tonnes over the past three years, Encana’s new processing plant in that same region starting emitting up to an additional 2.2 million tonnes of carbon emissions per year.

Aside from this ethical concern, however, I also had technical questions about whether Encana should have qualified for our tax money based on the stated standards of the trust and the regulations established by government. That’s when the CEO made a very interesting challenge to me. He quite forcefully and aggressively asked me if I was calling into question the two validators of the project (KMPG and an engineering firm) and the regulator of the industry (the Oil and Gas Commission). All three of these agencies had certified that the project qualified for our tax money and, therefore, according to the CEO I was supposed to be satisfied and, I guess, feel embarrassed that I was challenging such reputable entities.


My rebuttal to the CEO was to mention the Savings & Loan debacle in the U.S., Enron, the derivatives mess that caused the collapse of the U.S. economy, and the BP disaster. I could have gone on for a very long time listing situation after situation where regulators and validators told legislators everything was rosy when it most definitely was not. There is a long and sordid history of regulators and validators failing to protect the public interest with catastrophic results.

It is my duty to question regulators and third party validators. When legislators fail in this duty, history proves that the public interest is all too often not protected. So, yes, I am and will continue to question KPMG, engineers and the Oil & Gas Commission as well as the Pacific Carbon Trust about their use of public money and whether or not the projects this money supports meets the requirements of law, common sense, and some form of ethical standard.

In the case of Encana getting our tax money for a project that reduces emissions a tiny amount relative to their additional contribution to B.C.’s greenhouse gases, I’m still not convinced that project should have been certified to receive public money — the sign off of the regulators and validators notwithstanding.

Best regards,

Brian Kowalski

Outreach and Communications Coordinator

Bob Simpson, Independent MLA, Cariboo North




Just Posted

RDOS to study sites for composting facility

Penticton and Okanagan Falls landfills will be examined

Regional District of Okanagan Similkameen works to control mosquito populations

Control efforts in the region have been starting earlier each year

Reports of chaos in Penticton, involving police cruiser and possible shots fired

Residents also reported hearing shots fired at the same time as the crash

Driver held at gunpoint, car-jacked on East Side Road

Penticton RCMP are asking for the public to keep an eye out for the suspect, stolen vehicle

Penticton care aide training centre a first for the Interior

SafeCare BC Satellite Training Centre is now open in Penticton to help continuing care aides

VIDEO: Grizzly bears fight along northern B.C. highway in rare footage

Cari McGillivray posted the head-turning video, shot near Stewart, B.C., to social media

Caught on Camera: Boat catches fire at Okanagan marina

The cause of the fire is unknown at this time, no injuries were reported as a result of the blaze

Handgun crackdown, health spending and transit plans latest campaign promises

Friday was the end of a busy week on the campaign trail

B.C. woman photographs massive ant swarm on Abbotsford driveway

She asked what the ants were doing? The answer: war

Police arrest B.C. phone scammer linked to illegal call centres in India

Person arrested in Burnaby here on a work visa, says police

Air Canada forced girl, 12, to remove hijab: civil rights group

The San Francisco Bay Area office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations calling for change

Man from Winnipeg who was hiking alone found dead in Banff National Park

RCMP say the man was hiking alone on Mount Temple Thursday

Okanagan hosts Mexico for soccer

The Okanagan Masters League won both matches against their Mexican counterparts

Epic overtime battle, big turnout for memorial night to late owner of Okanagan hockey team

The KIJHL’s Kelowna Chiefs hounoured Grant Sheridan with a win in the team’s home-opener

Most Read