Issue challenges Canadian health care system

As a health care provider I have just been made aware this week of a very important issue, by health care colleagues in Vancouver,

To the Editor:

As a health care provider I have just been made aware this week of a very important issue, by health care colleagues in Vancouver, about a  pending legal challenge, that could have a major impact on the way we access health care.

While the case is not in the public focus, at least at present, it involves  a Vancouver  physician who is challenging, at the B.C. supreme court level, that the defining principle of Canadian medicare is unconstitutional. That defining principle, very simply, is that health  care services be provided according to patients’ needs and not their ability to pay.

How someone can reason that this basic principle of medicare is unconstitutional is beyond my comprehension of how the legal system works.

Nevertheless, Dr Brian Day, a Vancouver surgeon and a for profit clinic owner in Vancouver is seeking to persuade the Supreme Court that this is indeed  the case. If his challenge is successful then the rules that prevent a U.S. style system in our country would likely unravel and we would be in for a sea change in the way we access health care. While the case is being heard in B.C. and if Dr. Day is successful, there would be ramifications right across the country.

An organization called Canadian Doctors for Medicare has been given intervener status in this important case and is working hard to have this challenge defeated. In an email to many in the medical community this organization reported on audits of Dr. Day’s Cambie Street medical clinic which revealed evidence of extra billing, to a great extent, and overlapping claims, i.e., double dipping for the same service.

This case is to be heard on Sept. 8 this year. I think all we can do as private citizens is get the conversation going in our community as to whether or not we want a health care system which can put patients in incredible debt, which does not provide coverage for about  12 per cent  of its population and there really  is no evidence that it results in better care for patients.

Let us hope that our courts make the right decision.

Gerald Partridge MD, Keremeos


Just Posted

Keremeos man says stem cell therapy changed his life

Darryl Brewer says he went from being immobile with chronic pain to leading an active lifestyle

Okanagan-Shuswap weather: cloudy, showers expected

Environment Canada is predicting a mix of sun and clouds tomorrow and a sunny weekend across the Okanagan

Okanagan society sends seniors, shut-ins on boat excursions

Okanagan Quality Life Society has been providing Okanagan Lake boat rides for nearly 30 years

A rainy July is normal for the Okanagan

Rainy days in July haven’t been seen since before 2014

Updated: Former home of accused Penticton shooter vandalized

Ex-wife of man who is accused of murdering four people had her house vandalized

Rents in most Canadian cities are unaffordable for lower-income earners: study

Roughly one-third of households, or 4.7 million, are renters

Okanagan Basin Water Board continues call to protect B.C. waters from invasive mussels

The board is pushing for additional regulations from the government

Psychics, drones being used to search for missing Chilliwack woman with dementia

Drones, psychics, dogs and more have been employed to help find Grace Baranyk, 86

Summerland real estate agents handled many home transactions

Larry and Donna Young spent 40 years in Summerland housing market

Okanagan FC one win away from playoff berth

The Kelowna soccer club finishes their season with two home games

‘Benzos’ and fentanyl a deadly cocktail causing a growing concern on B.C. streets

Overdoses caused by benzodiazepines can’t be reversed with opioid-overdose antidote naloxone

Virtual reality, arcade gaming centre opens in Salmon Arm

Owner hopes to host city’s first Esports team for games like League of Legends, Fortnite

B.C. mom to go to Europe court in hopes of getting alleged abducted daughter back

Tasha Brown alleges her estranged wife abducted their daughter Kaydance Etchells in 2016

Scheer on Trump: It’s ‘offensive’ to question the family background of critics

Trump is being called a racist for saying that the four congresswomen should go back where they came from

Most Read