Public forum discusses concerns over genetically modified foods

MP tours riding to inform public about GM foods

  • Sep. 27, 2011 9:00 a.m.

The anti GM campaign is growing

BC Southern Interior MP Alex Atamanenko was in the Village of Keremeos last Wednesday, September 21 to host a forum on Genetic Modification and the future of food at Victory Hall.

Keynote speaker Lucy Sharratt, Coordinator of the Canadian Biotechnology Action Network (CBAN) joined Atamanenko along with April Reeves of the Society for a GE Free BC and local  panellists Lee McFadyen and Andrea Turner to bring residents up to date on the latest information on genetically modified crops and foods.

Sharratt was first to speak, emphasizing the concerns that the panel had with the relatively new science of genetic engineering.

“Genetic modification and genetic engineering mean essentially the same thing,” she told the gathering of  roughly 25.

“We feel that it is too early to apply the science to food. Not enough is known about the impacts GM foods could have on our health.”

Sharratt noted that there was 15 years of history behind genetic engineering. The first GM crop was canola, introduced in 1995. Corn, soy, white sugar beets and papaya are GM crops grown in the U.S.; there are seven GM crops grown globally.

“Consumer  backlash is slowing the spread of the science,” Sharratt continued.

“GM science has failed to fulfill its public promise.”

Originally, proponents of GM foods extolled such health benefits as a “cancer fighting broccoli,” but most of that message turned out to be public relations work, Sharratt said. Instead, the industry continues to lack labelling of GM products, there is continuing secrecy behind government decisions with respect to GM policy, and agriculturalists are finding herbicide tolerant weeds and insects growing resistant to toxins. Additionally, seed prices have soared.

“GM has certainly fulfilled its corporate promise,”  Sharratt added, noting the corporate monopolies behind the movement were reaping immense profits – and power – from their application of the science.

“There is a growing movement amongst consumers to gain control of how foods are grown,” Sharratt said, “and the question,  how does GM food fit in to the vision of food supply? is being asked.”

Three products are nearing commercial certification for genetic modification, alfalfa being one. There is fear over GM manipulation of the crop because of the huge risk of contamination to the non GM market.

Local panellist Lee McFadyen also noted that GM science had not lived up to its billing.

“High yields promised with the increased use of herbicides has resulted in herbicide tolerant weeds, and herbicide in everything,” she said. “Genetic modification is adding something into the environment that we don’t know enough about – are these substances detectable in human blood? Greater crop production hasn’t happened.

We should be insisting that GM products be labelled as well.”

Andrea Turner, a local orchardist, said local concerns over GM foods included a genetically modified apple that many growers were fighting.

We don’t want it,” she said.

Panellist April Reeves spoke of the introduction of GM plants that were modified to to produce toxins that would be fatal to insects that feed on the  plant.

“Food shouldn’t kill,” she said simply, “there’s got to be a consequence to this type of manipulation.” She pointed out that earlier in the day, at a forum in Osoyoos, Area “C” Director Allan Patton resolved to bring the matter of creating a “GM Free Zone” to the attention of the RDOS board of directors.

Alex Atamanenko spoke of his efforts to bring Bill C-474 to passage in the House of Commons last spring. He told the group about Wikileaks’ exposure of a Monsanto based conspiracy with the U.S. government to force the science on the public.

“The corporate sector has powerful control,” he said, “and the research they have done is corporate science – not independent.

A lot of advances have been stopped because people have intervened,” he added, noting  that  a population’s voice, united  in the matter could have a profound effect on the direction the science was going.

“GM alfalfa is the most important crop to be concerned about to date,” he concluded, “it’s becoming an issue of survival for our farmers.”

After messages from the panel were completed,  audience members posed questions, with a focus of interest regarding the politics surrounding the defeat of Atamanenko’s bill.

Sharratt also went into further detail with respect to the engineering process that creates genetically modified food, describing it as “an invasive and violent process.”

“The debate is whether gene manipulation matters or not,” she said. “What are the side effects, if any  – no one knows. One thing that is being focussed on is suppression of the immune system.

We are eating corn that contains toxins to kill insects. Is the toxin in our blood? The integrity of organisms is in question – or at risk.”


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

$30,000 over 30 weeks for local causes

Send us your good stories and you could win money for your favourite cause

First day back; attending elementary school amid COVID-19

“… Social connections are certainly important for kids,” said Carmi principal Dave Ritchie.

Grand Chief Stewart Phillip appeals for living-donor kidney transplant

Okanagan Nation Alliance Grand Chief has chronic kidney disease

Column: Penticton Regional Hospital returning to ‘new normal’

If we’ve learned anything over the last few months, it’s how important good health is in our lives.

Olympic athlete sends shout-out to Cawston Primary students

Canadian Olympic sprinter Khamica Bingham participated in one of the school’s long-time traditions

‘I’m pissed, I’m outraged’: Federal minister calls out police violence against Indigenous people

Indigenous Minister Marc Miller spoke on recent incidents, including fatal shooting of a B.C. woman

Kelowna Mountie who punched suspect identified, condemned by sister

‘How did he get away with this? How is this justifiable?’

Vernon protesters take Black Lives Matter movement to park

A handful of demonstrators raised fists, signs in solidarity Friday

Police watchdog investigating Lake Country incident

A man was taken to hospital after the June 3 incident

Community backlash over Black Lives Matter rally in Kelowna

Some members of Kelowna’s black community stated they don’t support Friday’s rally

PHOTOS: Anti-racism protesters gather in communities across B.C.

More protests are expected through the weekend

Pair accused of ‘horrific’ assault at Vancouver’s Oppenheimer Park at large

Police say Jason Tapp, 30, and Nicole Edwards, 33, did not show up to meet their bail supervisor this week

Bear strolls into Okangan homeowner’s living room

Conservation officers are searching for the bear, which entered a home in the Foothills area

Most Read